Plan mode tried to edit files

Plan mode created several points, and when tried to generate more plan items, it asked me to create implementation just during the planning phase

I expect to see and verify the plan and then implement it. Faced with this issue several months ago and nothing has changed.

This issue might be a duplicate of existing issues. Please check:

The model loops attempting to edit files in PLAN mode #3038: The model loops attempting to edit files in PLAN mode - This issue describes the exact same behavior where the model tries to edit files while in planning mode instead of staying in plan-only mode
READ-ONLY Plan #3146: READ-ONLY Plan - While this mentions read-only mode specifically, it's also about unexpected plan mode behavior

Feel free to ignore if none of these address your specific case.

yeah it's pretty annoying how the llm always tries to break free of the guardrails

the only foolproof way to fix is to remove the bash tool during planning but that tool can be helpful

Alternatives:

prompt iteration
try to automatically block common bash tool abuses with cat & sed for file edits

@NaikSoftware

Hey @NaikSoftware, this should be fixed

@berenar

@berenar thank you, will test it in the next several days

To stay organized issues are automatically closed after 90 days of no activity. If the issue is still relevant please open a new one.

Navigation Menu