A name is claimed once — the hosted binding lifecycle contract (pkgs/id hosted_binding)

Design doc: files/designs/code-id-hosted-binding-lifecycle.md in the keep-the-four-repos-healthy goal workspace. Audit HEAD: origin/main 8e151e89. Module: pkgs/id/src/hosted_binding.rs.

Summary

hosted_binding.rs binds a Google identity (sub) to an Iroh root key — the §3 challenge/pairing ceremony (slice 1, #3808) and the §4 delayed rebind protocol (slice 2, #3809 via #4885), both landed 2026-11-03. The module's header states its §3.4 failure table and §4 no-mutation contract in prose, but the transitions of its ephemeral state were never stated as one lifecycle, and three filings in one day are one counterexample per transition:

• Consumption (id(hosted_binding): expired challenge is recorded as consumed — a second presentation returns ChallengeReplay, and create_pairing_code's documented ChallengeReplay branch is unreachable #4868): submit_proof's expiry branch inserts the expired challenge into consumed_challenges (hosted_binding.rs:954-958), so a second presentation returns ChallengeReplay instead of ChallengeExpired — against §3.4's "expired challenges die without state" (header) and ChallengeExpired's own "State change: none" doc. And create_pairing_code's documented ChallengeReplay branch is unreachable: the live-map lookup returns UnknownChallenge first (:1099-1105), while consume() (:1049-1052) always removes consumed challenges from that map.
• Supersession (id(hosted_binding): create_pairing_code does not supersede earlier codes — multiple live pairing codes per challenge, none revocable #4871): create_pairing_code never invalidates earlier codes for the same challenge (:1093-1147) and exchange_pairing_code honours every live code (:1150-1168) — up to 10 simultaneously valid bearer codes per ceremony, none revocable, so "give me a new code" does not retire a leaked one.
• Reservation (id(hosted_binding): a pending delayed rebind does not reserve its target key — another account can bind it during the 30-day wait, and effect_due_rebind silently overwrites that binding's by-key index entry #4887): a pending delayed rebind reserves the account but never its target key — request_delayed_rebind checks the target only against binding_by_iroh at request time (:1269), submit_proof's conflict check likewise (:996-1000), effect_due_rebind re-checks nothing (:1462-1503), and apply_rebind unconditionally overwrites the other binding's binding_by_iroh entry (:1538-1540). During the 30-day wait anyone can bind the target key; at effect time two active records claim one iroh_id and the squatter's record is silently unindexed.

This audit adds a fourth surface of the same missing lifecycle: the rebind paths' shared verify_challenge_proof (:1171-1205) also consumes on expiry, and RebindError::ChallengeExpired's doc states the opposite of the ceremony side's — "it is consumed and dead." One module, two contradictory expiry semantics for the same challenge object.

The contract: every name the ceremony mints — a challenge, a pairing code, a rebind target key — is claimed exactly once, by exactly one holder, for exactly its stated lifetime, and every transition out of a live state (consumption, supersession, expiry, reservation, release) is named in the §3.4/§4 tables. Dead means the same thing on both error surfaces.

Checked and NOT stating this contract: #3809 (closed implementation slice) and #3818 (open, blocked — hosted bridge transport, gated on the #3808 contract, states no ceremony transitions). The Worker API slice (#3811) that will expose pairing over HTTP is not yet built; this contract lands before it does.

Decisions recorded

1. Expiry creates no state, on both surfaces. Expired challenges are removed from the live map and NOT inserted into consumed_challenges, in submit_proof and in verify_challenge_proof; RebindError::ChallengeExpired's doc is amended to match §3.4 in the same change. (The docs-amended-the-other-way alternative loses: replay is a security signal, expiry is not.)
2. A consumed challenge reports as consumed, everywhere. Every entry point checks the consumed set before the live map (the order submit_proof already uses), making create_pairing_code's ChallengeReplay reachable; UnknownChallenge means never-issued or expired away.
3. Minting supersedes. create_pairing_code removes every existing code for the challenge first — at most one live code per challenge. Rate limits unchanged.
4. A pending rebind reserves its target key. Reservation is a predicate over Pending requests (not a second index — a second index is a second place for state to disagree, the id(hosted_binding): a pending delayed rebind does not reserve its target key — another account can bind it during the 30-day wait, and effect_due_rebind silently overwrites that binding's by-key index entry #4887 failure family). submit_proof refuses a reserved key with IrohIdBoundElsewhere; request_delayed_rebind refuses a reserved target with NewKeyBoundElsewhere; the fast path gains the same check. Cancel/effect releases implicitly (the predicate reads only Pending).
5. Effect re-checks; the index write refuses a foreign entry. effect_due_rebind re-checks before any mutation (NewKeyBoundElsewhere, no state change, request stays Pending), and apply_rebind itself refuses to overwrite a binding_by_iroh entry naming a different binding.

Phases (sub-issues of this design)

• Phase 1 — id(hosted_binding): expired challenge is recorded as consumed — a second presentation returns ChallengeReplay, and create_pairing_code's documented ChallengeReplay branch is unreachable #4868 (ADOPTED): expiry creates no state (both challenge gates) + consumed-check order everywhere; docs amended in the same change.
• Phase 2 — id(hosted_binding): create_pairing_code does not supersede earlier codes — multiple live pairing codes per challenge, none revocable #4871 (ADOPTED, independent): minting a pairing code supersedes all earlier codes for the challenge.
• Phase 3 — id(hosted_binding): a pending delayed rebind does not reserve its target key — another account can bind it during the 30-day wait, and effect_due_rebind silently overwrites that binding's by-key index entry #4887 (ADOPTED, independent): target-key reservation + effect-time recheck + apply_rebind foreign-entry refusal.
• Phase 4 — NEW (closing audit): transition-table audit of every public method, the table written into the module header beside §3.4, four required dispositions (expired pairing-code sweep; consumed_challenges growth bound; reservation scan cost vs a target-key index; old-key-side symmetry confirmation), gated on Phases 1–3.

Open questions (recorded in the design doc, not phased)

• Must "expired" be sticky (a tombstone) once the Worker API (id: implement hosted Worker API + per-user DO provisioning and metering (from #2046/#2852 slice 3) #3811) maps these errors to HTTP? A client-contract question for that slice.
• Reservation notices to third parties whose ceremony is refused — a disclosure question, Drew's call if ever wanted, not a phase.

Acceptance for this design issue

All four phases closed with evidence; the module header carries the lifecycle transition table; #4868/#4871/#4887 closed by their phases (not re-filed).

Acceptance criteria

• The lifecycle contract is recorded (design doc + this issue) stating claim-once semantics for each ephemeral state in hosted_binding: pairing challenge, pairing code, rebind target key — holder, lifetime, and every named transition out of a live state (consumption, supersession, expiry, reservation, release).
• Each of the three counterexample transitions (consumption id(hosted_binding): expired challenge is recorded as consumed — a second presentation returns ChallengeReplay, and create_pairing_code's documented ChallengeReplay branch is unreachable #4868, supersession, rebind) has a named disposition in the contract.
• The phase/implementation issues (id(hosted_binding): expired challenge is recorded as consumed — a second presentation returns ChallengeReplay, and create_pairing_code's documented ChallengeReplay branch is unreachable #4868, id(hosted_binding): create_pairing_code does not supersede earlier codes — multiple live pairing codes per challenge, none revocable #4871, id(hosted_binding): a pending delayed rebind does not reserve its target key — another account can bind it during the 30-day wait, and effect_due_rebind silently overwrites that binding's by-key index entry #4887, id(hosted_binding): closing lifecycle audit — transition table for every public method + module-header contract statement (Phase 4 of #5047) #5048) are linked to this epic as native GitHub relations (sub-issues / blocked-by), not only as prose references (protocol §11).