UI to promote issue to PR

There's an API for converting an issue into a pull request. This is exposed in hub's pull-request subcommand. It would be aaaaawwwwweeeesssoooommmmeeee to have a web UI for this.

This is my personal number one feature request, hands down.

Here's the command I used to get the API to work for badges/shields#57:

curl https://api.github.com/repos/gittip/shields.io/pulls \
    -u $PERSONAL_API_TOKEN: \
    -X POST \
    -d'{"issue": "57", "head": "collapse-path-parts", "base": "master"}'

Here's some documentation for personal API tokens.

I sent an email to support@github.com about this.

Here's a workaround for now:
http://issue2pr.herokuapp.com/

Helpful to put it in your contributing.md

@patcon

@patcon I had trouble with that today, due to the new two-factor auth implementation.

@mtodd

@mtodd:

Hey Chad,

Thanks for sharing your feature request! We appreciate the feedback.

At GitHub, we prefer creating separate pull requests and then cross referencing the issue that it addresses. In the past, we've encountered problems when issues were turned into pull requests.

One simple example is when the pull request turns out to be the wrong solution and another pull request is more appropriate. In that case, it makes more sense for two separate pulls to both refer to the original issue.

Another example is when an issue's scope is bigger than just one pull request. In this case, several pulls can be created that refer back to the issue which each address different aspects of the overall issue.

Again, thanks for sharing. This has been on our minds and is something we're hoping to address in the future!

Cheers,
Matt

Hm. That's unfortunate. Seems rather overbearing if that's the official rationale :/

EDIT: When you submit emails, do you also link to the issue that you've created in this repo?

I couldn't get this working in hub (auth probs?) so I hacked this script: PRomote.sh.

Nice. FYI, hub --noop pull-request really helps debug when you're just getting used to using it.

Also, might be relevant: mislav/hub#399

Lastly, here's the format for the config file if you want to create it manually:

➜  drupal-monitoring git:(master) ✗ cat ~/.config/hub
--- 
github.com: 
- oauth_token: xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
  user: patcon

Oh hey, in case anyone missed it, there's talk of a make-do solution here:

steveklabnik/issue2pr#5

I don't want this anymore. Do I close this ticket or leave it open for others who do?

I've seen the sentiment elsewhere. Maybe leave it open?

This is a huge bummer, but it looks like github is discussing whether to deprecate the issue->PR feature :/

mislav/hub@d6b7e1b

Oh gosh, why am I finding out features only when they're about to be removed? :(

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

UI to promote issue to PR #93

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

UI to promote issue to PR #93

Description

Activity

chadwhitacre commented on Sep 6, 2013

chadwhitacre commented on Sep 6, 2013

patcon commented on Sep 6, 2013

chadwhitacre commented on Sep 7, 2013

chadwhitacre commented on Sep 7, 2013

patcon commented on Sep 7, 2013

chadwhitacre commented on Sep 10, 2013

patcon commented on Sep 10, 2013

patcon commented on Sep 10, 2013

zbynekwinkler commented on Sep 21, 2013

chadwhitacre commented on Dec 11, 2013

patcon commented on Dec 11, 2013

patcon commented on Jan 10, 2014

rlidwka commented on Jan 14, 2014

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions