Skip to content

Mythic Masters: beast detail hill climb to 9/10, rounds 2+ (from #2854) #3459

Closed

Description

@QuinnsCode

Continues the beast detail loop from #2854 (round 1, PR #2860), which had sunk to the bottom of the issues. Part of #2802 (the beasts from 3/10 to great). The animation and graphics climb is #3455; this one is the beast models only.

Where it stands

3/10, the owner's score for the beasts in #2802. Agent judges run about 2 points high on visual climbs (#2943: judges 5, owner 3), so read a judge's number as a direction.

Round What changed Result
1 (#2860) shaggy puca, plated imugi, nessie brow and teeth puca 4 to 6, imugi 4 to 6, nessie 4 to 5 (scales tried, dropped)
since builder detail parts (#2807, closed), silhouettes on sheets (#3072: 9 of 22 up a point, then stuck), materials and weighted normals (#3105) not judged as a round

One round

One worker, from main:

  1. bun run beasts, judge the contact sheets in apps/mythic-masters/blender/out/, score every beast out of 10, and put the scores in the PR.
  2. Pick the three lowest and name what reads wrong (bare back, sawtooth rim, flat face, blob legs, tiny head, tube legs).
  3. Fix it with an existing part in the sheet first. Only add a part to blender/beast.py when no part can do it, with a row in its field list and a README line.
  4. Rebuild, check the feet and wing counts still match, rescore with a fresh judge (BEFORE vs NOW), and keep the change only if the score went up.

Rules that stay: one sheet always builds the same GLB, and every sheet's feet come out as rig tips.

Menu for the next rounds (open issues this climb draws on)

Part ideas not built yet: claws and toe pads, whiskers, gill slits, dorsal frills, horn ridges, eyelids.

Ending a round

Comment here, first line Score: x/10 (target 9), then the shots, then Next: <the judge's top gap>. The PR says "Part of #", never a closing word. Then hop forward (bun run climbs has the baton text).

Activity

  1. QuinnsCode commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @QuinnsCode
    OwnerAuthor

    Score: 3/10 (target 9)

    The owner's score for the beasts (#2802), carried over from #2854. Round 1 there moved puca, imugi and nessie up 1-2 points each.

    Next: fix the cropped beasts.ts --judge shots (#3132) so a round can be judged, then run the judge for #3105 (#3109) as the new BEFORE.

  2. self-assigned this
    on Nov 4, 2026
  3. QuinnsCode commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @QuinnsCode
    OwnerAuthor

    Score: 3/10 (target 9). Round 2 (#3495) fixed the judge: close-up contact sheets, held still, so BEFORE and NOW compare. No art changed, so the score holds. Moved up to #3494.

    Next: the art round in #3494.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

No labels
No labels

Projects

No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions