Repository navigation
Description
Continues the beast detail loop from #2854 (round 1, PR #2860), which had sunk to the bottom of the issues. Part of #2802 (the beasts from 3/10 to great). The animation and graphics climb is #3455; this one is the beast models only.
Where it stands
3/10, the owner's score for the beasts in #2802. Agent judges run about 2 points high on visual climbs (#2943: judges 5, owner 3), so read a judge's number as a direction.
| Round | What changed | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1 (#2860) | shaggy puca, plated imugi, nessie brow and teeth | puca 4 to 6, imugi 4 to 6, nessie 4 to 5 (scales tried, dropped) |
| since | builder detail parts (#2807, closed), silhouettes on sheets (#3072: 9 of 22 up a point, then stuck), materials and weighted normals (#3105) | not judged as a round |
One round
One worker, from main:
bun run beasts, judge the contact sheets inapps/mythic-masters/blender/out/, score every beast out of 10, and put the scores in the PR.- Pick the three lowest and name what reads wrong (bare back, sawtooth rim, flat face, blob legs, tiny head, tube legs).
- Fix it with an existing part in the sheet first. Only add a part to
blender/beast.pywhen no part can do it, with a row in its field list and a README line. - Rebuild, check the feet and wing counts still match, rescore with a fresh judge (BEFORE vs NOW), and keep the change only if the score went up.
Rules that stay: one sheet always builds the same GLB, and every sheet's feet come out as rig tips.
Menu for the next rounds (open issues this climb draws on)
- Mythic Masters: beast --judge shots are a cropped strip, so paired scores can't be read #3132:
beasts.ts --judgeshots are a cropped strip and some pages are blank, so paired scores can't be read. Fix this first, or no round can be judged. - Mythic Masters: judge run for #3105 (BEFORE vs NOW beast gallery) #3109: judge run for Mythic Masters: beast materials, weighted normals, lifted dark hides (#3096) #3105 (materials) never happened. Mythic Masters: look at Cadejo and Hidebehind renders after #3105 #3110: Cadejo and Hidebehind renders after Mythic Masters: beast materials, weighted normals, lifted dark hides (#3096) #3105.
- Mythic Masters: beast silhouettes round 2: builder parts for heads, feet and wings #3071: builder parts for heads, feet and wings (sheets alone stopped at +1 for 9 of 22).
- Mythic Masters: beast round 3 on the 40 untouched beasts, and fix slab-like limb thighs #3093: round 3 on the 40 beasts no round has touched, and the slab-like limb thighs.
- Mythic Masters: builder fixes the second art pass hit (Nessie blend, feather tips, sphinx wings, tufts in blobs) #2795: builder fixes left from the second art pass (Nessie blend, feather tips, sphinx wings, tufts in blobs).
- Mythic Masters: second detail pass per region with the new builder parts (after #2807) #2808 / Mythic Masters: first detail pass, Africa and Europe (regions 17-45): faces, hands and feet, markings with today's parts #2818 / Mythic Masters: check the regions 46-64 detail pass in ?gallery and in a fight, and give the biters open mouths #2874: detail passes per region (Africa and Europe not started; 46-64 needs open mouths, which can be built now that Mythic Masters: builder detail parts for the beasts (scales, teeth rows, ears, broad feathers, fur rooted on blobs) #2807 is closed).
- Mythic Masters: screenshot judging and phone frame-rate check for the #2820 effects #2830: effects shot judging and phone frame rate.
- Owner taste on the earlier passes: MANUAL RUN MANUAL RUN: judge the Americas detail pass in the gallery and a fight (PR #2856) #2858 (Americas), MANUAL RUN: judge the Asia and Oceania detail pass in the gallery and a fight (PR #2873) #2888 (Asia and Oceania).
Part ideas not built yet: claws and toe pads, whiskers, gill slits, dorsal frills, horn ridges, eyelids.
Ending a round
Comment here, first line Score: x/10 (target 9), then the shots, then Next: <the judge's top gap>. The PR says "Part of #", never a closing word. Then hop forward (bun run climbs has the baton text).
Activity
QuinnsCode commentedon Nov 4, 2026
Score: 3/10 (target 9)
The owner's score for the beasts (#2802), carried over from #2854. Round 1 there moved puca, imugi and nessie up 1-2 points each.
Next: fix the cropped
beasts.ts --judgeshots (#3132) so a round can be judged, then run the judge for #3105 (#3109) as the new BEFORE.QuinnsCode commentedon Nov 4, 2026
Score: 3/10 (target 9). Round 2 (#3495) fixed the judge: close-up contact sheets, held still, so BEFORE and NOW compare. No art changed, so the score holds. Moved up to #3494.
Next: the art round in #3494.