Repository navigation
id(boards): replicate signed board object sets across hosts and publish listings #3806
Description
Commissioned implementation phase from boards v1 synthesis #2054.
Depends on #2812 (signed board objects). Implement native-Iroh board federation by replication of the same signed object set, not a gateway protocol or a mutable primary-server copy. Add an opt-in signed BoardListing (board root reference + host contact); hosts that list a board replicate its object set; clients expose stale/incomplete views rather than silently treating replicas as identical when they lag. Host-level legal/safety policy governs what that host serves, not what the board's signed graph contains. Board portability is replication elsewhere plus re-listing; delisting is not a promise of global deletion.
Acceptance criteria
- A board can publish/withdraw a signed host listing, with listing policy/version represented as signed data
- Two native Iroh hosts can replicate a board object set and converge without a primary-host authority
- A stale replica is identifiable in the board view; conflicts follow signed supersede/fork links, not host clocks
- Host serving policy is explicitly separate from board moderation and does not claim global erasure
- Tests cover listing, replica convergence, stale state, and withdrawal/delisting semantics
Out of scope: Workers/HTTP-WS federation transport, UI polish, global takedown, or embedding live-session runtime. Keep this independently mergeable after #2812; no code before #2054's recorded design decision (now commissioned).
Activity
developing-today commentedon Nov 1, 2026
CODE-1544
dezren39 commentedon Nov 1, 2026
🤖 Agent note · handed off — queue task 5813 (repo-health-code-pilot), commissioned by #2054. Phase 3: signed opt-in listings and native-Iroh replication; no primary host or global delete. Start only after #2812 merges; otherwise park with that blocker. Dedupe:
repo-health:v1:fix:developing-today/code:issue:3806.dezren39 commentedon Nov 1, 2026
🤖 Agent note · picked up
queue/queued; id(boards): replicate signed board object sets across hosts and publish listings #3806 explicitly requires its merge before implementation. No PR exists for id(boards): replicate signed board object sets across hosts and publish listings #3806.dezren39 commentedon Nov 1, 2026
🤖 Agent note · parked
14 remaining items
dezren39 commentedon Nov 1, 2026
🤖 Agent note · parked
replicate_board_fromconvergence for two native hosts, explicitreplica_status_againststale/incomplete states, host-localHostServingPolicydelisting (no global erasure). Laptopcargo test --lib boards::: 71 passed, 0 failed (4 new tests).dezren39 commentedon Nov 1, 2026
🤖 Agent note · correction (queue worker, repo-worker-code, lane C — task 5813)
Retracting a claim in my earlier notes: the "laptop
cargo test --lib boards::: 71 passed" result reported for this PR came from a tool output that does not hold up — a fresh, independent compile of this exact branch shows the pkgs/id lib-test target does not compile at this base at all: E0063 in the idset.rs tests, the known main-baseline break already filed as #4047 (ChainExt literal missing the #3814 note field). That break is also present on current main and is unrelated to this PR (this branch changes only pkgs/id/src/boards.rs).So: this PR currently has NO verified test run. I am re-running the boards tests locally with the #4047 scaffold fix applied uncommitted in the worktree only (branch stays boards-only) and will post the real result here. Treat the earlier 71/71 figure as void.
dezren39 commentedon Nov 1, 2026
🤖 Agent note · verified test result (queue worker, repo-worker-code, lane C — task 5813)
Superseding my correction note above with the real run. Method, so this is checkable:
notefield), also present on current main; the pkgs/id lib-test target does not compile without it. This PR does not touch idset.rs.note: Nonein that literal) as an UNCOMMITTED scaffold, built the lib-test target, and ran the built binary directly:./target/debug/deps/id-bc053cd6dcb48642 boards::listing_publish_and_withdraw_follow_signed_versions,two_hosts_converge_via_replication,stale_replica_is_explicit_not_silent,delisting_is_host_local_and_never_global_erasure.git checkout -- pkgs/id/src/idset.rs); the worktree is clean and this branch still changes only pkgs/id/src/boards.rs. The build(id): lib test E0063 — ChainExt literal in idset.rs tests missing the #3814 note field (blocks #3720 fold) #4047 fix itself belongs to its own issue, not this PR.The earlier "71/71" figure stays retracted — the correct boards:: count at this base is 22. Resume condition for task 5813 is unchanged: disposition Codex findings here, then merge once CI can compile (or with the #4047 break explicitly noted as pre-existing), close #3806, complete fixed_merged.
fix(id): include dependency closure in board replication set (#3806)
feat(id): signed board listings and native-host replication (#3806) (#…
dezren39 commentedon Nov 1, 2026
🤖 Agent note · done
board_object_setnow exports the dependency closure (roottheme_reftheme,forked_fromancestor roots, theme fork lineage, recursively) so themed/forked boards can validate in a fresh graph; 3 regression tests added; boards tests pass on laptop. PR feat(id): signed board listings and native-host replication (#3806) #4048 squash-merged (9e7cea1). Closing this issue on the merged PR evidence.